Return to Watch District 46 Schools Home Page
 
Tempers Flare at Forum
Grayslake Times, April 13-19, 2001
(reprinted with permission)

By HELEN MANSFIELD
Staff Reporter

    Nearly 300 hundred parents and
concerned Grayslake residents
attended the four-hour forum to
discuss strategic planning for
Community Consolidated School
District 46.
    They were there to voice concern
over hiring William Spady, a sociologist
who was the originator of
Outcome-Based Education (OBE).
    Ask anyone, pro or con, and they
will tell you Spady is one of the most
controversial proponents of school
reform.
    During the public portion of the
regular school board meeting, parent
Mary Pirrello addressed the board
telling them she had four reasons to
oppose OBE, her four children.
    She said she moved to Grayslake
six years ago from Connecticut
where her children attended an OBE
school district. There, she said the
district was plagued as the students
were not performing as promised.

 “Writing skills were down,
reading skills were slipping and math
skills were barely holding up against
the rest of the country,” she read
from a prepared speech.
    Teaching from the standpoint
that “all children can learn” OBE
pushed one of her children into a
grade she was not prepared for,
where another child was bored and
unchallenged, becoming what was
described as a “non-performing
intellect.”
    During the forum, board of
education members spoke to the
audience addressing issues that had
been brought to their attention.
Audience members were then asked
to write any additional questions on
three by five cards.
    Several residents took issue
with the format, citing that everyone
who wanted to comment for
the record would not get an opportunity
to do so.
    Board Member Sharon Rogers
Werneke said that a new strategic
plan was important as the district
hasn’t had a new one since 1990. The
district, she added, has changed a
great deal since then.
    In ‘90 Dist. 46 had 1,200 students.
Now there are 3,400.
    Board Member Nancy Arens said
they initially went with Spady
because “he would ask the tough
questions.”
    Each board member reiterated
the fact that no changes have been
implemented since Spady was put
on the payroll and that there will be a
number of additional forums with
the public before anything is decided.
    Superintendent Dr. Kurt Anderson
said that he didn’t believe that
Spady would be involved in the final
implementation.
    Board Member Kathy Lucas said
that perhaps Spady was the right
choice for the position because the
very discussion of him brought the
crowd in that night.
    Following the event, Anderson
said he thought the meeting went
well, though upcoming strategic
planning discussions had to be
postponed due the sudden death of
Spady’s mother.
    “Most research tells us that
successful organizations experience
conflict,” he said. “We have a tendency
to think that conflict is bad, but
without it, there’s no growth.”
    The next community meeting
will be Tuesday, April 24 at 7 p.m. at
Frederick School. The public is invited.

 

Return to Watch District 46 Schools Home Page